Crash, Canvas, and Crucible: Air India’s Fight for Relevance After Air India flight 171

“Fifteen seconds.”

That was the brutal arithmetic between the mayday call from flight AI 171 and the moment the Boeing 787 ripped through the hostel block of B. J. Medical College on 12 June 2025.

For the 230 passengers, 12 crew, and 19 people on the ground who perished, fifteen heartbeats marked the boundary between routine ascent and aviation’s deadliest single event of the decade.

I received the first alert on my phone at 13:48 IST, while connecting in Doha.

By the time my onward flight boarded, every cockpit in the Region, Europe, and Asia Pacific had heard the bulletin: “Dreamliner hull-loss in Ahmedabad.” Within hours, insurers, regulators, and the investment community began asking the question Air India thought it had left behind with its 2022 privatization: “Is the Maharajah cursed?”

1 | Air India flight 171 and the ‘Fifteen-Second Gap

Minutes after rotation, AI 171’s engines spooled down; the 787 settled into an uncommanded descent—475 feet per minute—while still nose-up and wings-level. Captain Sumeet Sabharwal’s voice reached Ahmedabad Tower: “Mayday, mayday, may—”. Impact came less than fifteen seconds later; ATC never had time to vector the jet back to runway 23. Investigators now cite a dual-channel FADEC failure tied to a transient power interruption, a one-in-a-billion scenario Boeing engineers contemplated but never saw outside the simulator.

For Air India the tragedy shredded a two-year-old narrative carefully stitched by the Tata Group: “Rebirth, reliability, renaissance.” Instead, global feeds looped the same footage—charred carbon-fiber, smoke curling through shattered windows.

The world’s first fatal Dreamliner crash happened under Air India’s new livery.

2 | Legacy on Trial, From Tata Air Services to Vista Blue

To understand what’s at stake we must rewind almost a century. In 1932 J. R. D. Tata flew a single Puss Moth carrying mail from Karachi to Bombay, profit: ₹60,000, passengers: 155, mystique: priceless. Post-war nationalism converted Tata Airlines into Air India, and for a glittering decade the carrier stood shoulder-to-shoulder with Pan Am and BOAC, the first Asian airline to fly jets (B707, 1960) and later the palace-in-the-sky 747.

Then came the slow bleed: 1970s fuel crises, 1990s liberalization, the ill-fated 2007 merger with Indian Airlines, and a debt pile larger than most Indian states’ education budgets. By FY 2021, cumulative losses sat above US $9 billion.

The 2022 Tata-Singapore Airlines consortium buy-back looked audacious, some said philanthropic. It came with a five-year transformation blueprint, “Vihaan.AI,” and an order for 470 new Airbus and Boeing aircraft.

Marketing agency FutureBrand wrapped the reboot in a royal-red and vista-blue colourway, retired the flying swan, and refreshed the Maharajah. Yet painting history is easier than erasing muscle memory. Frequent flyers still carried mental images of frayed seat cushions and half-warm lemon rice.

3 | India’s Skies in 2025-IndiGo’s Hegemony and the GCC Squeeze

While Air India turned wrenches and re-trained crew, IndiGo hoovered up domestic demand. The low-cost giant now commands about 60 per cent of India’s passenger traffic, a figure that sounded inconceivable when it took delivery of its first A320 in 2006. IndiGo’s mastery is banal efficiency: 30-minute turns, two-classless cabins, razor-thin CASK. Its brand promise is simply “no surprises.”

Long-haul, the competitive set wears a different uniform. Emirates, Qatar Airways, and Etihad funnel South-Asian diaspora and Europe-bound holidaymakers through gleaming Gulf hubs, offering flat beds, shower-spas, and schedule density Air India cannot yet match. Throw in Singapore Airlines—paradoxically Air India’s minority owner—and the Maharajah finds himself besieged on both frontiers of his kingdom.

4 | The Rebrand in Numbers: Progress or Optics?

Pillar	Target (announced 2022)	Status mid-2025	Commentary
Fleet Renewal	470 new aircraft by 2030	78 delivered; 22 more this FY	Supply-chain snags delaying A350 lavatory retrofits
Cabin Retrofit	67 legacy jets by 2026	11 complete	777s ahead; 787 programme paused pending AI 171 findings
Service Culture	Net promoter score 40→70	Currently 44	Cabin-crew churn 18 % p.a. after wage harmonisation
On-Time Performance	59 %→85 %	63 %	Still lowest among top-5 Indian carriers
Financial Break-Even	FY 2026	EBITDA -INR 2,100 cr (FY 24)	Brent $84/bbl and rupee slide hurting

Progress is real but uneven. The A350-900 showcased at Wings India drew rave reviews—six-abreast premium economy, Thales AVANT IFE, artisan latté foam shaped like the Konark wheel—but those jets represent less than 5 % of ASKs. Most paying customers still board a 12-year-old 777 with incandescent bulbs and a broken seat-back latch.

5 | Psychology of Trust—Why Incidents Cost More Than Hulls

Economists tally fatalities; marketers track sentiment; accountants model yield dilution. After AI 171, searches containing “Is Air India safe?” spiked 2800 % on Google India. In loyalty science we call this negative availability bias—vivid disasters overshadow millions of uneventful flights. McKinsey research finds carriers lose 11 per cent of premium-cabin revenue in the quarter following a fatal crash, even when investigators ultimately exonerate maintenance procedures.

For Air India, the timing is savage. The airline is halfway through its Vihaan overhaul, burning cash on new hardware, while revenue planners hoped to lift average fares 8-10 % on freshly reconfigured routes. A sustained shock to demand could push break-even back two years.

6 | Three Strategic Levers—Can the Maharajah Still Rise?

I offer three levers—hard-won from two decades watching airlines flirt with oblivion.

Lever 1 | Radical Transparency, Not Euphemisms

The first official press note after AI 171 spoke of a “loss of thrust event.” Lawyers may cheer such phrasing; passengers do not. Emirates, in 2016, posted cockpit audio and maintenance logs within 72 hours of its EK 521 hull-loss; bookings recovered in nine days. Air India must adopt a similar posture:

• 72-Hour Rule: Release verified FDR/CVR extracts or at least a timeline reviewed by DGCA.

• Live FAQ: Update families, media, and social channels every six hours until the final report.

• Compassionate Claims Portal: Single-click compensation requests; avoid the paperwork maze that haunted AI 229 victims in 2010.

Trust lost early costs double to regain later.

Lever 2 | Operational Boringness—The IndiGo Playbook

Air India will never beat a Gulf carrier on opulence, but it can win on predictability at home. That means:

• Block Times Realism: Inflate schedule padding; absorb monsoon ATC delays.

• Turnaround SWAT Teams: Borrow IndiGo’s “Red Cap” philosophy—one lead accountable per aircraft, per sector.

• Tech Uptime Metrics: Publish real-time aircraft-on-ground (AOG) statistics; incentivize engineering chiefs on minutes-of-delay, not just dispatch reliability.

  
  

When your weakness is perception of chaos, aim for the excitement level of a Swiss commuter train.

Lever 3 | Alliance Leverage & the Vistara DNA

Post-merger Vistara has vanished as a brand, but its culture need not. Ex-Vistara crews boast India’s highest Skytrax satisfaction scores; integrating their SOPs system-wide can uplift soft service faster than any consultant. Meanwhile, Star Alliance remains an under-exploited asset. Code-sharing deeper into Lufthansa, United, and ANA networks can:

• Fill premium cabins with status-hungry elites.

• Spread risk while AI’s own 787 fleet undergoes safety retrofits.

• Offer through-checked assurance—critical when brand trust ebbs.

  
  

7 | Gazing at 2030—The Scenario Matrix

Scenario	Market Share (Domestic)	Long-Haul Load Factor	EBITDA Margin	Narrative Headline
Phoenix (30 % prob.)	22 %	84 %	+6 %	“Maharajah Masters Middle Kingdom”
Plateau (50 % prob.)	16 %	77 %	+1 %	“Credible #2 to IndiGo, Feeder to Star”
Spiral (20 % prob.)	<12 %	68 %	-4 %	“Vista Blues: Asset Sale or JV?”

My base case is the Plateau: Air India claws to a respectable 16-17 % domestic slice—roughly where Jet Airways once sat—while carving a profitable niche in nonstop India-US and India-Australia services that bypass Gulf hubs. The Phoenix requires flawless execution of Vihaan, no further safety shocks, and a supportive oil market. The Spiral looms if labour unrest, another incident, or sustained rupee weakness collide.

8 | Can They Beat IndiGo and the GCC Heavies?

Against IndiGo: the low-cost titan feeds on simplicity. Air India can differentiate through wide-body frequency on metro pairs (e.g., DEL–BOM) offering lie-flat at marginal cost, a trick Jet used effectively pre-2018. More crucially, corporate contracts value alliance connectivity, Star beats IndiGo’s solo act.

Against Emirates/Qatar/Etihad: the Maharajah’s ace is geography. A non-stop Delhi–San Francisco flight is two hours faster than a Dubai stop-over. If Air India maintains a 70 % dispatch reliability on ultra-long-haul, time-sensitive VFR and tech traffic will pay a premium. But cabin service must rise to at least “good” to neutralize the Gulf carriers’ “excellent.”

9 | A Personal Epilogue—Why I’m Still Bullish

I walked the production line at Toulouse earlier this year; the A350-1000 for Air India gleamed in Vista blue. A young Indian engineer, on secondment from Bengaluru, pointed to the tail and smiled: “I watched my dad avoid this airline all my life. Now I paint his future ride.” Culture shifts one heart at a time.

The tragedy of Air India flight 171 has cast a long shadow yet in the world of aviation, recovery is not just possible, it’s expected.

And in India, where the skies are now home to the world’s fastest-growing aviation market, the stakes and the opportunities have never been higher.

With Tata Group’s long-term vision, Singapore Airlines’ operational discipline, and the resources already in motion, from fleet modernization to service transformation, Air India has the right architecture to become more than just a credible alternative, It can lead.

Yes, the challenges are real. But so is the moment.

The Maharajah doesn’t need to rise from ashes, but he needs only to return to the role he was once built for: an Indian brand that leads the world, not chases it.

And in this new chapter of Indian aviation, that comeback may already be underway.

To learn more about Anjuna Airline Solutions you can refer to: https://www.anjunagsa.com/services